The Energizer

Resilient Insights for Work & Life

Five Reasons Panels At Meetings FAIL

by Eileen McDargh, Chief Energy Officer - Saturday, March 22, 2014
Featured Image
Some of the key findings from a recent survey on panels by colleague and fellow facilitator Kristin Arnold include:
  • Panels are pervasive. The panel format is widely used at meetings. Ninety-nine percent of respondents have seen a panel format during a meeting in the past 12 months.
  • Panels are a lazy format. The panel format is considered to be a relatively easy format to produce: the meeting planner picks the topic, finds a moderator, selects the panelists and then moves on to more important aspects of the meeting. Unfortunately, the audience sees this lack of attention and doesn't enter into the panel space with high hopes.
  • Format needs to be updated. The traditional, boring panel format needs to be reinvigorated to engage and entertain today's audiences.
  • Skilled facilitation is key to panel success. There is a high degree of correlation between the effectiveness of the moderator and the effectiveness of the panel in achieving the outcomes. Having a skilled facilitator as the moderator is your best insurance policy to creating a successful panel session.
  • Choose moderators wisely. A company official might not be the wise choice at bringing out the best in panelists. The biggest "pet peeve" is having a poor moderator, with out-of-control panelists following close behind. This makes perfect sense - when you have a skilled moderator, then the panelists will be less likely to get out of control. Yet when you have a lousy moderator, even brilliant panelists can get out of control or miss the mark.
I will add one more: plenty of pre-work.  If possible, we get potential questions in advance from the representative audience. I interview and talk to all a panelists before hand.  This creates a level of comfort between us. I highlight that this will be a conversation and not a presentation. If possible, I assemble the panelists beforehand, in either a breakfast or dinner meeting so they are comfortable with each other.  Lastly, we create a living room set on the stage and I often will move from the stage to be part of the audience and field their questions to the panelists. To find out more please call me at 949-496-8640 to discuss!

Share This Post

Like this post? Please share it!

< Back to All Posts


Eileen McDargh Keynote Speaker Blog Author

About Eileen!

Since beginning her consulting and training practice in 1980, Eileen has become noted for her ability to speak the truth with clarity, wisdom, humor and compassion. Long-standing clients and repeat engagements attest to her commitment to make a difference in minds, hearts and spirits of organizations and individuals. She draws upon practical business know-how, life's experiences and years of consulting to major national and international organizations that have ranged from global pharmaceuticals to the US Armed Forces, from health care associations to religious institutions. Executive Excellence magazine selected her as one of the top 100 thought leaders in leadership and among the top ten consultant providers of leadership development.

View all posts by Eileen

Subscribe to My Blog!

Like My Blog?

Please share it!

Recents Posts




Change holidays coaching waiting Positive Brain Repatterning Loss Married Humor cancer John Havlik New Year resolutions Women Leaders Open Doors Book More Fun at Work Survive Patriots Book Reviews resilient organizations Career Advice Guns Volunteer customer service Back To School Seder Eve Children Branding Politics Faith Writing Yoga earthquakes Connection Interview Option B Exercise Radical Resiliency work life balance Twas The Night Before Christmas Adaptability Reshaping the Brain Jewish resilient leaders Spelling Bee Laughter goals e-mail LGBTQ Vacation Thanksgiving Alzheimer's creativity preresilience Bullying Motivating Others Animals Conversation Happiness Compassion Environtment Intentions The Last Jedi Stress John Mattone Mother's Day WASP Networking Requisite Variety Hurricane Harvey Depression Henry VIII Breathe Multi-tasking Energizing Napping Mark Scharenbroich Climate Change Dogs Building Resilience Resolutions ecology Loneliness Hurricane Irma Bill Treasurer Sheryl Sandberg Sustainability Christmas love Nursing Walk For Hunger gratitude Office Celebrations Honoring Veterans Charity Soft Skills Relationships Divorce Communication Disrupt USAA Learned Optimism Empathy Human Interaction St. Patrick's Day resilience Road Trip Humanity Sexual Harassment teams Superbowl Marriage Arlington Cemetary Emotional Intelligence Corporate Culture Sleeping Kindness Breath Burnout Ecotourism angels Siblings Listening Content Generation Meetings employees Tornadoes in Texas Words Time Management employee retention Boston Marathon Family Energy Travel Strangers Talk Ain't Cheap Book Gifts From The Mountain Diversity Trust Suddenly Single civil discourse Employee Attitude Leadership Skills Fun Work Environment Idea Memorial Day Vegan Ownership Energizing Others Joy Technology Adventure Engaged Workers Sales Disruption Spirit John Blumberg conscience Adam Grant Your Resiliency GPS Play Social Media resiliency Aging Speaking Art Optimism Deloitte Persuasion Postive Work Environment Feedback women in leadership U.S.A.A. Voting